Real Estate Listing Appointment Tips | The Seller Conversations Nobody Teaches You

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | RSS

Real Estate Listing Appointment Tips: The Seller Conversations Nobody Teaches You

Picture this. It is week four of a listing. The house has had six showings and zero offers. Your seller calls you on a Tuesday morning and the first thing out of their mouth is not hello.

They want to know what you have been doing. They want to know why nobody is making an offer. And somewhere under all of that, they want someone to blame. Guess whose number they called.

This is the moment most agents completely fall apart.

They get defensive. They start explaining. They quote market statistics while the seller gets angrier. They leave the call feeling beat up and unsure whether they still have the listing.

Debbie De Grote has coached agents through this exact moment more times than almost anyone alive. She started in real estate at eighteen, closed over 3,000 transactions in her selling career, became the first agent ever inducted into the Century 21 Hall of Fame, and has spent the last 25 years as one of the most sought after coaches in the industry. She has been on over 100,000 private coaching calls.

In this episode she walks through exactly what to say, what not to say, and how to completely change the dynamic of the hardest conversations in real estate.

The Best Defense Is a Good Offense

Here is Debbie’s most important point and she makes it early. The agents who handle difficult seller conversations best are not the ones with the best scripts for when things go wrong. They are the ones who had the right conversations before anything went wrong.

Think about the difference between two scenarios. In the first one, an agent takes a listing, puts it on the market, and calls the seller only when there is news. Weeks go by. The seller has been watching the days on market tick up. They have been telling their friends the house is listed. And now they want answers nobody gave them ahead of time.

In the second scenario, the agent sits down after the listing is signed and says something like: here is what the first few weeks are going to look like, here is how many showings are typical for a home priced like this, here is what I am going to be doing each week, and here is the conversation we are probably going to have in about three weeks if we are not seeing the activity we want. The second agent does not get ambushed. They get a call from a seller who already knows what to expect.

Proactive communication is not just a nice gesture. It is the foundation of the whole thing.

The First Two to Three Weeks Are the Whole Game

Debbie is emphatic about this and the data backs her up. The first fourteen to twenty one days of a listing are when it gets the most attention, the freshest eyes, the most motivated buyers.

After that, days on market starts telling a story to every buyer who sees it. Not a good story. Buyers start wondering what is wrong with it. They start lowballing. Some just skip it entirely. The longer a home sits, the harder it becomes to sell it at the original price, and often the harder it becomes to sell it at all.

This is why Debbie says the pricing conversation and the expectation conversation have to happen before the listing goes live, not after three weeks of disappointing results. The window for getting it right is much smaller than most sellers realize, and most agents never tell them that.

Let the Data Do the Talking

One of the biggest mistakes agents make in a price reduction conversation is making it personal. They say things like I think we need to lower the price or in my opinion the market is telling us something. And the seller immediately has someone to disagree with. You.

Debbie teaches agents to take themselves out of it. Show the seller what comparable homes sold for. Show them what is sitting on the market right now and for how long. Let them see the pattern themselves. When the data makes the case, the agent becomes the guide instead of the bad news.

The script she recommends sounds something like this: Let me show you what is happening out there right now and then we can talk about what it means for us. Notice the word us. Not you. Not your house. Us.

Use We, Us, and Our

This sounds almost too simple to mention but Debbie says it changes everything. Language that positions the agent as a partner changes the emotional temperature of the conversation.

When you say your home is overpriced it sounds like an accusation. When you say based on what we are seeing in our market, let me walk you through our options, it sounds like two people solving a problem together. The seller is not being told what to do. They are being invited into a decision.

Sellers in difficult conversations are often scared. They have a lot riding on this. The house might represent their retirement, or their kids college fund, or the ability to move closer to family. When they feel like they have an ally instead of an agent who is just trying to close a deal, the conversation changes completely.

Even No News Is News

Debbie makes a point that sticks with you. Even when there is nothing to report, that is information and your seller deserves to hear it from you.

Silence does not read as nothing happening. It reads as neglect. A seller who does not hear from their agent for two weeks fills in that blank with anxiety. They start wondering if the agent is still working the listing. They start looking at other agents websites. They start having conversations with their spouse about whether they made the right choice.

A weekly call or message that says here is what we did this week, here is what the market looks like right now, and here is what I am thinking for next week costs almost nothing. The trust it builds is enormous. The problems it prevents are significant.

When They Shoot the Messenger

So what do you actually say when the seller comes at you angry?

Debbie’s answer is that the first thing you do is not explain yourself. You listen. You acknowledge. You let them feel heard before you say anything that sounds like a defense or a plan.

Something like: I hear you and I completely understand why you feel that way. This is not what either of us wanted. That sentence alone changes the energy of most conversations. The seller is no longer fighting against you. They are sitting next to you.

Once the emotion comes down, then you bring the data. Then you bring the options. Not before.

Give Options, Not Opinions

This is one of the more practical frameworks Debbie shares. When a seller asks what they should do, most agents give their opinion. That is a trap. The moment you tell a seller what to do, you own the outcome. If it does not work, the blame comes back to you.

Instead, Debbie teaches agents to present two or three clear choices and let the seller decide. Option one is we hold the price and adjust our marketing approach. Option two is we reduce the price by X and here is the likely impact. Option three is we take it off the market and relaunch in the spring. Each option has a realistic outcome attached to it. The seller makes the call.

This does two things. It keeps the seller in control of their own decision. And it protects the agent from owning outcomes that were never fully in their control.

The Hardest Conversation Usually Comes Too Late

Debbie’s broader point is that most of the painful seller conversations agents find themselves in did not have to happen. They are the result of not having a harder conversation earlier.

Taking an overpriced listing to avoid conflict with a seller almost always creates more conflict down the road, at a point when the listing has been sitting long enough that the options are worse. The honest conversation at the listing appointment, the one where you tell the seller exactly what the market will bear and exactly why, is uncomfortable for maybe ten minutes.

The conversation six weeks later when the home is stale and the seller is angry is uncomfortable for months.

Confidence Comes From Having a Plan

The reason most agents dread these conversations is not that they do not care about their clients. It is that they show up without a plan. They have not thought through what they are going to say. They have not pulled the comparable sales. They do not have a recommendation ready.

When you walk into a seller update with a clear picture of what has happened, what you have done, and what you recommend next, the confidence is automatic. You are not hoping the conversation goes okay. You are leading it. And sellers can feel the difference.

The Real Point

Debbie De Grote has had more difficult seller conversations than almost anyone in this industry. And her conclusion after all of it is this: uncomfortable conversations do not damage relationships. Avoiding them does.

The agents who build the most loyal client bases are not the ones who only show up with good news. They are the ones who show up every time, with honesty, with empathy, and with a plan. Those clients refer everyone they know because they know they can trust what you tell them even when it is not what they want to hear.

That is the whole job.

🎧  Listen to the full episode here (embed your player above)

Connect with Debbie: forwardcoaching.com

Free price reductions course: info.forwardcoaching.com/pricereductionspodcast

KEY TAKEAWAYS

• The best defense is a good offense. Difficult conversations become easier when expectations are set before problems arise. Proactive agents rarely get ambushed.
• The first two to three weeks are the whole game. Days on market changes how buyers perceive a listing. The pricing conversation needs to happen before it goes live, not after it sits.
• Let the data tell the story. When the market makes the case, the agent becomes the guide instead of the bad news.
• Use we, us, and our. Collaborative language positions you as a partner solving a problem together, not an adversary delivering bad news.
• Even no news is news. Silence reads as neglect. A weekly update builds trust even when there is nothing new to report.
• Empathy before data. When a seller gets emotional, acknowledge their feelings before you explain anything. People want to feel heard before they want advice.
• Give options, not opinions. Let the seller decide between two or three clear choices with realistic outcomes attached. Do not own decisions that are not yours to make.
• Confidence comes from having a plan. Agents who show up prepared lead the conversation. Agents who show up hoping for the best get steamrolled.
• Uncomfortable conversations do not damage relationships. Avoiding them does. The most trusted agents are the ones who show up with honesty every time, not just when the news is good.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00  Introduction to the uncomfortable side of real estate

1:38  Meet Debbie De Grote and Forward Coaching

3:28  Lessons learned through multiple real estate market cycles

4:39  The toughest seller conversation: my house isn’t selling

5:32  Why pricing conversations must be handled carefully

6:58  Setting expectations before problems arise

8:42  Negotiating future price reductions upfront

9:27  Using collaborative language with sellers

10:32  Creating a consistent communication plan

11:56  Why the first 14 to 21 days are critical

13:11  The dangers of excessive days on market

14:12  When market time starts hurting a listing

15:56  How to wow sellers during the first week

17:20  The question every listing agent should ask

18:25  Managing communication expectations effectively

19:35  Delivering updates with confidence and strategy

21:20  Why sellers often shoot the messenger

22:26  Using empathy to handle emotional reactions

24:02  Why all decision makers must be part of the conversation

25:22  Handling low offers professionally

27:40  What to say when sellers ask for your opinion

28:55  The power of presenting three options

ABOUT DEBBIE DE GROTE

Debbie De Grote began her real estate career at age 18 and quickly became one of the nation’s top-producing agents. Over a 16-year sales career, she closed more than 156 transactions annually, completed over 3,000 career transactions, and became the first agent inducted into the Century 21 Hall of Fame.

For the past 25 years, Debbie has been recognized as one of North America’s premier real estate coaches, working with elite agents, brokers, mortgage professionals, title representatives, escrow officers, and insurance professionals. She has conducted more than 100,000 private coaching calls and remains one of the industry’s most sought after speakers and trainers.

Website: forwardcoaching.com

Free Course: Price Reductions Podcast Course

Email: debbie@forwardcoaching.com

LinkedIn: Forward Coaching

Instagram: @forward_coaching

Facebook: Forward Coaching

FAQ  —  PEOPLE ALSO ASK  (USE GUTENBERG FAQ BLOCK IN WORDPRESS)

How do I tell a seller their house is overpriced?

Let the data make the case instead of your opinion. Pull comparable sales and active listings and walk the seller through the pattern. When the market is doing the talking, you become the guide rather than the person delivering bad news. Debbie De Grote recommends using language like let me show you what is happening in our market right now and then we can talk about what it means for us. The word us matters. You are solving this together, not delivering a verdict.

What do I say when a seller gets upset about a price reduction?

Start with empathy before anything else. Something like I hear you and I completely understand why you feel this way. This is not what either of us wanted. That one sentence changes the emotional temperature of most conversations. Once the seller feels heard, then you bring the data and the options. Never lead with logic when someone is emotional. They cannot hear it until they feel acknowledged.

How do real estate agents handle difficult seller conversations?

The agents who handle them best are the ones who had the hard conversations before problems started. Setting expectations immediately after taking a listing, discussing likely showing activity, possible market shifts, and what a price adjustment conversation might look like down the road removes the element of surprise when those things happen. Proactive communication every week, even when there is nothing new to report, builds the kind of trust that makes hard conversations survivable when they arrive.

How do I manage seller expectations when the market slows down?

Start before the listing goes live. Walk sellers through realistic showing projections for their price range and neighborhood. Explain how days on market affects buyer perception and negotiating power. Have the price reduction conversation hypothetically before it becomes a real one. Sellers who are prepared for multiple scenarios are far less likely to panic when the market does what markets do. Debbie De Grote calls this going on offense before you have to play defense.

What should I say when my listing has no showings?

Call the seller before they call you. Have a weekly update ready that covers what marketing activity happened, what the market looks like right now in terms of comparable competition, and what your recommendation is for the week ahead. Then give them two or three options and let them decide. Sellers can handle hard news when they feel like their agent is on top of it. What they cannot handle is silence followed by a phone call they had to make themselves.

How do I avoid being blamed when a listing does not sell?

Set expectations early, communicate consistently, and give options instead of opinions. When a seller makes the call on pricing, marketing adjustments, or timing, the decision belongs to them. Your job is to make sure they have the best possible information to make that call, and that they know you are doing everything in your power to get the result they want. Agents who document their communication and their recommendations rarely end up in disputes with sellers.

INTERNAL LINK SUGGESTIONS

“AI Can Replace a Lot. It Will Never Replace Your Relationships.”

“The Kitchen Table Close“ (Amanda DiVito Parle) 

“You Don’t Have a Lead Problem. You Have a Conversion Problem.”